10-2SG Craftsburt Conservation Commission
Grant Round:
2010 September
Grant Program:
Small Grants
Grant Type:
Other Grants
Grant amount requested:
2,500.00
Attachments
Please provide a brief description of the project for which you seek funding.
Green Mountain Power, Vermont’s second largest utility, applied on May 21, 2010 to the state Public Service Board for a “Certificate of Public Good,” in order to construct 21 turbines on 3.2 miles of unroaded Lowell Mountain ridgeline in the town of Lowell. (This is the Kingdom Community Wind Project which is locally known as the Lowell Mountain Wind Project.) The town of Craftsbury, arguably with the most outstanding views of the project area, subsequently filed a “Motion to Intervene,” essentially a request to participate in the review process. Quoting from the town Selectboard’s motion: “Craftsbury lies at the southern terminus of the so-called “viewshed” of the project. The dominant view to the north and northwest from any number of points within the Town are the Lowell Mountains, location of the proposed project, the completion of which has a potentially profound effect on historic sites, aesthetic quality and economic interests of the region. The Town’s primary economic resource is its relatively healthy, unspoiled landscape. In many respects the Town personifies the entire state featuring prominent, untrammeled ridges, mountains and cultivated valleys. The increasing importance of recreational travel as a significant economic factor in The Town must be acknowledged. One has only to look at the increase in facilities for catering to this need: bed and breakfast operations, recreational facilities catering to “self-propelled” activities, a small college dependent to some degree on our existing landscape and the Town’s increasing presence in travel brochures as a destination for other commercial touring operations. In brief, how the Town “looks,” is of great importance to local economic health and the Town itself must participate in the process in order to assess the effects of the proposed project.”
Briefly stated, our “project” is to assure a fair and complete review of the town’s issues and concerns before the state Public Service Board. Note the timeline of these hearings again and that they have begun and who has been attending them The town has one of the highest tax rates in the state and no public resources for hiring professional counsel to assure proper representation. While local volunteers are invaluable in helping define local values and needs—a volunteer, Selectboard-approved, private fund-raising effort is underway to raise funds for hiring such representation--the Public Service Board review process (Act 248) is an arcane, attorney-driven exercise that makes it difficult for local, untrained volunteers to participate effectively. The Lowell mountain wind project case has begun and we are without legal counsel before the PSB hearings. Adjudication of the Certificate of Public Good application will go on through spring of 2011 when the Public Service Board will hand down its decision. The Craftsbury Conservation Commission and selectboard have been involved months before May 21 when Green Mountain Power submitted an application for a Certificate of Public Good. We need to hire an attorney for the short-term now. That’s the role of the requested NEGEF grant. Local fund-raising will support this position for the longer term. We cannot predict the likelihood of an appeal until a decision—by the PSB –is made.
Members of the Craftsbury Conservation Commission will attend PSB hearings in Montpelier as well as a scheduled site visit and public hearing proposed for September 23, 2010. Reports on these events and all breaking news regarding the project will be available on the town’s website, a special section dedicated to the project. See our role in cooperating with Sterling College on local presentations and guest speakers. We are also staying connected with our town colleagues o the Energy Committee and the Planning Commission.
At the request of the Craftsbury Selectboard, the Craftsbury Conservation Commission held an informational meeting in the town hall on August 3, 2010. This was an opportunity for the selectboard to hear the resident concerns and issues regarding the wind project. Over 50 Craftsbury residents attended this meeting and the comments and questions were recorded. Answers to some of these questions plus additional information about the wind project have been posted on the town website. A message board has been established to promote a continued discussion about the project. The conservation commission is working with other groups, Craftsbury Energy Committee and Sterling College, to host additional informational meetings and presentations. September 16 Sterling College will host a discussion on the issue of industrial wind projects on mountain ridgeline. On the 15th we are hosting a visit from staff members of the Vermont Natural Resources Council in an effort to show them first hand our concerns with this project. VNRC is currently drafting a statewide policy statement on siting wind turbines.
Primary Issue Area:
Climate Change & Energy
Please break-down/categorize the program expenses:
| Proposed Item | Estimated $ Amount | Would grant funds be used for this item? |
|---|---|---|
| Legal Counsel | $30,000.00 | Yes |
| Outreach Simulation | $1,000.00 |
Whom does your group need to make this project happen?
Please explain how your group will engage members from your community in this project.
Community engagement is an every day process for us; as individuals, we have historically been engaged in community activities. With regard to this project we are engaged when we stop at the Post Office, buy gasoline at the local garage, pick up some necessities at either of two general stores, have dinner with friends or take the dog for a swim at the local lake. In a more regimented context all our activities are reported on the website and we are just now working out the details of a Conservation Commission Facebook page. For the past three months we have been a primary item on the Selectboard’s agenda. Each of our meetings is covered by at least one local newspaper. Additional volunteers from the community have emerged during our engagement on this project. Our information session was a resounding success. The last time more than 50 people showed up in one room in Craftsbury was the 2010 Town Meeting.
With regard to neighboring towns, on August 31, 2010, members of the Craftsbury Conservation Commission—at the request of the Irasburg Selectboard—gave a similar presentation for Irasburg residents. Others from surrounding towns, especially Albany and Lowell, also attended. Neighboring towns have had a strong interest in Craftsbury’s process since the turbine project has siginificant effects throughout the region.
Four area newspapers—Hardwick Gazette, Barton Chronicle, Newport Daily News and St. Johnsbury’s Caledonian Record have been covering this issue. The best of the four has been the Gazette whose reporter lives in Craftsbury.
If your group receives a NEGEF Grow grant, how do you plan to pay for remaining expenses?
| $ Amount | Source |
|---|---|
| $2,500.00 | NEGEF Grant |
| $28,500.00 | Town fund |
Please list these materials or services
| $ Amount | Item |
|---|---|
| $12,800.00 | Volunteer - 640hr @ $20/hr |
Please describe what changes will occur in your community and its environment when your group's project is successful.
Three changes will occur.
1) Townspeople will better understand the value of a natural, untrammeled landscape. Our regular interaction with the Town Energy Committee and The Town Planning Commission ( we are currently drafting a Natural Heritage segment for the Town Plan).ONGOING
2) The Conservation Commission will have properly presented the town’s case—its “interests and concerns”--before the state Public Service Board. GOAL: BY COMPLETION OF HEARINGS, SPRING 2011.
3) The case will help spur a local, regional and state-wide conversation about proper siting of industrial-sized wind turbines leading to a comprehensive state policy on such actions. Such a policy will better protect the values that Vermonters deem important. GOAL: TO COINCIDE WITH PSB DECISION ON THE LOWELL WIND FACILITY
The broader goal is to initiate a regional and statewide conversation on wind turbine siting in rural areas, in effect addressing the questions: What is the value of Vermont ridgelines and mountains? Should they be reshaped in order to accommodate this form of renewable energy generation? We believe the experience here in Vermont’s Northeast Kingdom can lead to a statewide conversation.
Please list how many people in your community your group expects to actively engage in this project.
50
What relevant skills does the group need (but does not currently have access to) to help move the initiative forward?
Better understanding of internet potential in advancing our case. Better fund-raising skills. The capacity to work without sleep.